Share this post

🔢 Key Takeaways

  1. Philadelphia's reputation for sports booing doesn't define its overall spirit - the city has a history of challenging the status quo and fighting for progress.
  2. Booing may be seen as disrespectful, but it is also a reminder of the power of the people and their right to express public opinion. As technology advances, we must consider the importance of active audience participation in society.
  3. Booing may not be polite, but it can provide useful feedback to performers and express audience frustration with a lackluster show. It's up to the individual to decide whether or not to boo.
  4. The high cost of Broadway tickets and the endowment effect might explain the absence of booing. However, audience demand characteristics and occasional booing can indicate authenticity and passion from the audience.
  5. Silent booing can provide a cathartic outlet for expressing feelings about a show while still giving valuable feedback to producers. Booing shows that audiences care about quality performances and have high expectations.
  6. Getting booed may hurt, but it's an opportunity to learn and improve. Being open to constructive feedback is essential for success, regardless of your level of expertise.
  7. Booing can express dissatisfaction and engagement in a democratic society, but it's essential to use it thoughtfully and respectfully. Good-natured booing is allowed, but it's important to know the rules in different contexts and handle it as a politician.
  8. Responding to booing with humor or a clever comeback can help turn a negative situation into a positive one. Marginalizing the booers can also make the audience rally behind the speaker or athlete.
  9. Athletes strive to please their fans, but booing can snowball and hurt terribly. They make mistakes and are vulnerable to criticism like everyone else.
  10. When faced with criticism, using creativity to connect with others can turn a challenge into an opportunity for understanding. Take a cue from Johnnie LeMaster, who turned boos into cheers with a simple act of self-expression.
  11. Negative reactions can be a sign of success and kind words from respected individuals have the power to inspire and uplift us.

📝 Podcast Notes

The Passionate Spirit of Philadelphia

Philadelphia is known for being the capital of sports booing, where passionate fans will boo lack of effort, opposing players, and even Santa Claus. The infamous Santa Claus booing incident of 1968 at Franklin Field involved a scrawny-looking Santa named Frank Olivo, who actually said he would've done the same thing himself if he wasn't on the field. Despite its reputation for boisterous fans, Philadelphia has an important legacy as the cradle of the political part of the Revolution, with historical dissidents such as Thomas Paine. This suggests that Philly's famed passionate spirit isn't limited to sports, but has a deep-seated tradition of challenging the status quo and fighting for a better future.

The Decline of Booing: What it Says About Audience Participation Today

In Thomas Paine's time, audiences were expected to react and interact during public speeches and theatrical performances, exhibiting huzzahs and boos. However, today, booing has declined in popularity except in sports. Though booing can be considered vandalism, it is an expression of democracy. Robert Lipsyte, a writer for The New York Times, notes that booing is a reminder of audience sovereignty and the power of the people. It is an expression of public opinion. As we move towards a more digitized world, it begs the question of whether we have lost the tradition of active audience participation and expression.

To Boo or Not to Boo: Critiquing Park and Bark Opera Performances

Opera singers who lack acting abilities and simply stand and sing, known as 'park and bark' performers, can be disappointing to watch, especially when they don't put in their best effort during their final performances. Despite this, some audiences may still refrain from booing, even if it's warranted. However, some individuals, like theater critic Terry Teachout, feel compelled to express their disappointment through boos when they feel a performance hasn't met their expectations. While booing may not be the most polite form of criticism, it can provide feedback to performers and convey the audience's frustration with a subpar show.

Exploring the Psychology of Booing in Broadway and Other Venues

The absence of booing on Broadway might be attributed to the high cost of tickets, as people feel obliged to make the most of the substantial investment they make. The endowment effect, where the value of something increases simply because it belongs to us, might also be at play. However, the fact that people boo in other venues, such as opera houses, suggests that demand characteristics of the situation might be shaping audience response. Theatre critic, Terry Teachout, suggests that occasional booing might actually be encouraging, as it would indicate a sense of authenticity and passion from the audience.

The Potency of Silent Boos for Audience Feedback

The idea of using a silent boo to express dissatisfaction with a performance has been suggested as an alternative to full-scale incivility, such as throwing tomatoes. Some argue that checking a box on a customer satisfaction survey does not have the same visceral impact as booing, but the silent boo could provide a cathartic outlet for expressing feelings about a show. It could even supply useful information to the producers of the show. Nonetheless, booing is viewed as a natural expression of frustration and disappointment when a performance does not meet expectations. The fact that audience members have high expectations and are willing to boo shows that they care about the quality of the performance.

The Art of Embracing Constructive Criticism

If you've made it to the big leagues, getting booed may come with the territory. This is true in any industry, including entertainment. Amateur performers on the other hand, don't usually get booed because the audience knows they are not professionals. However, at the legendary Apollo Theatre in Harlem, even amateurs can get harshly critiqued. If the audience doesn't like an act, they can vote with their voices, and the Executioner will come and remove them from the stage. Getting booed can be a painful experience, but it can also be an opportunity to learn and grow. Embracing constructive criticism is key to success, whether you are a professional or an amateur.

The Art of Booing: Rules and Contexts

Booing is an art form that has different rules in different contexts. At the Apollo, it's not okay to boo kids, but it's acceptable to boo in the name of Jesus or to some politicians. Good-natured booing is always allowed, especially towards popular politicians. Ed Rendell, a former governor of Pennsylvania, has shared his rules for booing, including the importance of knowing how to handle booing as a politician. Booing can be an expression of dissatisfaction, but it can also be a form of engagement and participation in a democratic society. Whether online or in-person, booing can have consequences, and it's essential to use it thoughtfully and respectfully.

Turning Booing into an Advantage

In political speeches, responding to booing can turn the situation around like how George Bush the elder did in a Michael Dukakis debate in 1988. By marginalizing the booers and characterizing them as not representing the majority, a speaker can turn an episode of booing into a supportive episode of applause. Similarly, Johnnie LeMaster turned booing into a supportive episode during his Major League Baseball career when he hit a game-winning home run after being booed by the crowd. These examples show that responding to booing with humor or a clever comeback can help a speaker or athlete gain the upper hand and turn the situation around. Such reactions demonstrate that seemingly negative situations can be turned into positive outcomes with a little creativity and strategic thinking.

Johnnie LeMaster on the Painful Experience of Being Booed by Home Crowd

Johnnie LeMaster, a former baseball player, shares his experience of being booed by his home crowd during a rough patch with the Giants. He explains how an athlete wants to please his fans the most, but once booing starts, it snowballs, and it hurts incredibly bad. LeMaster acknowledges that he may have added fuel to the fire by making a few errors and saying things in the newspapers that he shouldn't have said. However, he believes that people are fickle, and once something gets started, it's tough to stop. It's a reminder that athletes, like everyone else, make mistakes and are susceptible to criticism from others.

The Power of Creativity in Overcoming Backlash

Johnnie LeMaster, a baseball player in San Francisco, faced backlash from fans after expressing conservative views on homosexuality. In response, LeMaster made a jersey with 'Boo' on the back, worn as a way for fans to cheer him instead of booing him. The move got the fans and media off his back and became a lasting legacy, still talked about thirty years later. The incident highlights the power of creativity in navigating challenges and turning them into opportunities for connection and understanding.

The Power of Booing and Kind Words

Reggie Jackson, the famous baseball player, once told a fellow player who was being booed, 'people don’t boo nobodies.' This simple phrase had a profound impact on the player and made him feel like a million bucks. What can we learn from this story? Perhaps it’s that negative reactions, such as booing, can actually be a sign of success rather than failure. Maybe it’s that a few kind words from a respected individual can make all the difference in someone’s day, week, or even life. Ultimately, there may not be a grand theory behind booing, but the stories that surround it have the power to inspire and uplift us.