Share this post

🔑 Key Takeaways

  1. Unexpected opportunities can arise from pursuing interests and being open to new experiences.
  2. Justin Gary's experience in debate competitions taught him valuable skills such as persuasive speaking, logical thinking, and adaptability, which contributed to his success in various aspects of life.
  3. Developing strong persuasive abilities, efficient time management, and pursuing competitive gaming opportunities can lead to success and financial rewards in the industry.
  4. Magic: The Gathering's success stems from its immersive game design, socialization opportunities, competitive aspirations, and the emphasis on continual growth, making it a popular and long-lasting game.
  5. Magic allows players to customize their gaming experience through constant introduction of new cards, offering freedom to create unique strategies and characters, enhancing enjoyment and growth.
  6. Never give up in the face of setbacks. Take calculated risks, stay determined, and learn from past experiences to achieve future successes.
  7. Success is not only about personal achievements but also about lifting others up and thriving together. It's important to pursue fulfillment rather than winning the wrong game.
  8. Following your passion, even if it seems uncertain or unconventional, can lead to great fulfillment and success. Embracing discomfort and stepping out of your comfort zone is necessary, but the journey will ultimately be rewarding.
  9. Creativity is not innate, but can be developed through a structured process, motivation, seeking guidance, and practicing simple exercises to enhance creative thinking.
  10. Questioning assumptions and thinking outside the box can lead to breakthrough ideas and opportunities, enabling us to find innovative solutions and explore new possibilities.
  11. Questioning assumptions and testing them leads to more effective decision making in various fields, such as publishing and game design.
  12. The creative process involves steps such as making connections, eliminating ideas, prototyping, and iterating. Setting parameters and constraints, utilizing brainstorming tools, and pushing through obstacles are key to successful projects.
  13. Prioritize functionality over aesthetics and focus on the core design and idea when prototyping. Embrace a quick and dirty approach to save time and effectively explore ideas.
  14. Don't be discouraged by initial roughness. Embrace iteration and fast prototyping, be open to change, and avoid getting caught up in sunk cost fallacy and resistance to change.
  15. Leadership is not about having all the answers, but about being willing to make assertions and learn from the consequences, leading to personal and professional growth.
  16. Prioritize assessing risks, saving for a cushion, and being methodical to have the freedom to make long-term decisions as an entrepreneur.
  17. By valuing your work and not undercharging, you can overcome rejection and find the appropriate value for your services. Pursue projects that are fulfilling and enjoyable to create something meaningful.
  18. Focus on creating something you love and believe in, gather feedback from others, and continually invest in your product to achieve positive traction.
  19. In the game development industry, success is driven by using available resources creatively, taking risks, and validating market demand. Resourcefulness and adaptability are essential for creating appealing and successful games.
  20. Having a great product is essential, but it is equally important to find unique ways to draw people in and gather real-life feedback to separate yourself from the crowd.
  21. Feedback should be specific, consider nonverbal cues, and come from a variety of testers. While problems may be accurately identified, proposed solutions may not always be the most effective.
  22. Pay attention to patterns and themes in user feedback, as multiple individuals expressing the same concern should be taken seriously. Even visually appealing designs should be omitted if they are confusing or not understood by the target audience. Collaboration and partnership can lead to significant benefits.
  23. Despite challenges and delays, Justin Gary's choice to retain ownership of his game allowed him to explore various expansion opportunities and ultimately succeed in the tabletop game industry.
  24. Define your own success and purpose in the industry, avoiding solely chasing money, and stay true to your objectives throughout the entrepreneurial journey.
  25. The importance of realistic financial planning, adaptability, and determination in the face of adversity.
  26. Communication, honesty, and humility are essential in partnerships. Embrace failures, recognize limitations, set clear goals, give constant feedback, face challenges, and maintain a winning mindset for business success.
  27. Structuring clear goals, using a company Discord, and prioritizing accountability and effective communication are essential for productivity and success in any remote work setting.
  28. Trusting your team to take initiative and make decisions can result in their personal and professional growth, leading to better outcomes and a more empowered team.
  29. Letting go of the need for control and accepting the unknown brings peace and fulfillment in all aspects of life.

📝 Podcast Summary

The Unexpected Success of Magic: The Gathering

Magic: The Gathering is a trading card game that combines elements of chess, poker, and fantasy characters. It involves strategically constructing decks of cards and making tactical decisions during gameplay. Justin Gary, the guest of the podcast, became involved in Magic through playing competitively in a laser tag league. He initially underestimated the importance of deck construction and strategy but eventually learned and improved. At the age of 16, he won a state championship tournament, which led to an invitation to the national championships. This unexpected success in Magic shaped Justin's journey as a game designer and entrepreneur. The key takeaway is that unexpected opportunities and successes can arise from pursuing interests and being open to new experiences.

How Debate Competitions Shaped Justin Gary's Success

Justin Gary's experience in debate competitions had a significant impact on his success in other aspects of life. His participation in debate tournaments allowed him to develop persuasive speaking skills, logical thinking, and the ability to think on his feet. These skills later proved to be valuable when he pursued a career in playing Magic professionally and in other areas of his life. In debates, Justin had to choose a side and present his case within a limited time frame, responding to his opponent's arguments. Judges would then determine the winner based on the persuasiveness and logical strength of the arguments presented. This experience taught Justin the importance of framing his arguments effectively and being able to adapt to different topics and counterarguments.

The Importance of Persuasive Skills, Time Management, and Financial Rewards in Competitive Gaming

Being a successful competitor, whether in debating or playing Magic, requires strong persuasive abilities and efficient time management. Justin Gary emphasizes the importance of actively listening to opponents and taking concrete notes to address each point effectively. By refuting their arguments and presenting their own in a strong and concise manner, competitors can gain a time advantage and make it difficult for opponents to properly address and attack everything. Furthermore, Justin highlights the profitability of being a full-time Magic player during his time in the industry. Winning tournaments could result in significant cash prizes, allowing players to earn a substantial income. Overall, this conversation highlights the significance of persuasive skills, time management, and the potential financial rewards in the competitive gaming industry.

The Elements that Make Magic: The Gathering a Global Phenomenon

Magic: The Gathering, as a game, has successfully tapped into several key elements that resonate with players and contribute to its global phenomenon. The game's design encompasses immersion, connection, aspiration, and growth, which are all desired experiences for players. Magic offers an immersive experience by allowing players to craft their own stories within the game. It also encourages socialization and connection with others through gameplay. Additionally, the game fosters a sense of aspiration by providing opportunities for competition and achievement. Lastly, Magic promotes growth by encouraging players to continually learn and improve their skills. These factors, combined with the dopamine potential of buying booster packs, have contributed to the game's immense popularity and longevity.

The Power of Customization in Magic: Crafting Unique Strategies and Decks

Magic allows players to customize and own their gaming experience. Unlike games like chess, where there are limitations on learning and customization, Magic constantly introduces new cards and opportunities for players to craft their own unique strategies and decks. Just like in Dungeons and Dragons, players have the freedom to tell their own story and create their own characters. This level of customization and immersion is what makes Magic and similar games so powerful and appealing to game designers and players alike. The idea of balance in games is important, but it does not mean that everything has to be equal. The excitement of discovering and combining different cards adds to the enjoyment and growth of the gaming experience.

Triumph through Redemption and Perseverance

Redemption and perseverance are powerful motivators. Justin Gary shares his personal story of facing disappointment after losing at the world championships, but his determination to redeem himself drives him to continue pursuing success. He trains rigorously with his team, sacrificing time and resources to improve their skills. In a nail-biting final match, Justin takes a risky decision to mulligan his starting cards and ultimately achieves victory. This highlights the importance of taking calculated risks and never giving up despite setbacks. Justin's success demonstrates the transformative power of determination, dedication, and the belief in one's abilities. It serves as a reminder to always strive for redemption and learn from past experiences to achieve future triumphs.

A Journey of Personal Growth and Collaboration

Justin Gary experienced a significant shift in mindset and perspective. He realized that success in Magic and other individual games was centered around his personal achievements. However, his journey in the team-based world championship taught him the importance of lifting others up and thriving together. This change in focus not only impacted his approach to Magic but also influenced how he worked with other teams. Additionally, Justin's experience in law school taught him a valuable lesson about pursuing the wrong path and winning the wrong game. He realized that it can be more detrimental to succeed in something that doesn't bring fulfillment than to lose in something you genuinely enjoy. This realization prompted him to explore other opportunities, such as working on a Marvel comics card game.

Embracing Passion: The Key to Fulfillment and Success

Taking a path that aligns with your passion and interests, even if it seems uncertain or unconventional, can lead to great fulfillment and success. Justin Gary's decision to leave law school and pursue a career in game design, despite initial resistance from his mother and societal pressures, turned out to be one of the best decisions he ever made. It is important to recognize that fear and uncertainty are often illusions created in our minds, and there are always ways to recover or pivot if necessary. Following your true passion may require stepping out of your comfort zone and embracing discomfort, but it can ultimately lead to a fulfilling and rewarding journey.

Unleashing Creativity through Process and Practice

Creativity is not exclusive to a select few, but can be cultivated through a process. Justin Gary initially believed that creativity was a special talent possessed by others, and he felt like an imposter in the creative field. However, he discovered that the key differentiating factor between creative and non-creative individuals is their approach and process. As an analytically minded person, he developed a six-step process called the core design loop that can be applied to any creative field. Deadlines and the pressure of his job also served as motivators for him to act and produce creative work. Furthermore, seeking guidance from books and mentors played a crucial role in accelerating his creative growth. Justin also recommends the book "A Whack on the Side of the Head" for its ability to demystify and simplify the creative process. By adopting simple exercises, such as looking at objects from different perspectives or using random constraints, individuals can enhance their creative thinking and break free from linear problem-solving.

Unleashing Creativity Through Challenging Assumptions

Challenging assumptions and breaking away from traditional constraints can lead to innovative and unexpected solutions. Justin Gary and Tim Ferriss discuss the power of using random constraints and unconventional thinking to spark creativity. They share examples of how questioning assumptions led to new ideas and opportunities. For example, Justin Gary's game, Soul Forge, was originally designed as a digital game but through challenging assumptions, they discovered the potential of using new technology to create a physical card game. Tim Ferriss also mentions his exploration of writing a book and how he is questioning the traditional format and considering alternative approaches. By challenging assumptions and exploring different perspectives, we can discover new possibilities and innovative solutions.

Challenging Assumptions for Informed Decision Making

It is important to question and test assumptions in order to make informed decisions. Tim Fessiss brings up the assumption in publishing that books should always go to paperback after the hardcover release. However, he questions the logic behind this practice and realizes that it doesn't make sense financially in a world where ebooks are available. By challenging this assumption, he has been able to make strategic decisions for his own books. Similarly, in game design, Justin Gary emphasizes the need to question assumptions and set constraints to guide the creative process. By challenging and testing assumptions, individuals can make more informed and effective decisions in their respective fields.

The Creative Process and its Steps

The creative process involves several steps, including making connections, filling gaps, elimination, prototyping, testing, and iterating. This process can be applied to various projects, such as starting a podcast or writing a book. It is important to set parameters and constraints to keep the project interesting yet manageable. Brainstorming plays a crucial role in generating ideas and can be done using different tools, such as whiteboards, pen and paper, or digital apps like WorkFlowy. When it comes to prototyping, finding the easiest and fastest method is essential. Many people often get stuck during or after the prototyping stage, and it is important to push through and continue iterating to improve and refine the project.

The Importance of Simplicity and Speed in Prototyping

When it comes to prototyping, simplicity and speed are crucial. Many individuals, including Tim Fessiss, tend to struggle with the prototyping phase, striving to create something polished and perfect right from the start. However, Justin Gary emphasizes the importance of keeping it simple and not overdeveloping the prototype. He shares his experience with creating the deck-building game Ascension, where his initial prototype was made by shuffling Dominion cards together to test a randomized gameplay concept. Justin highlights the need to focus on the core design and idea first, rather than getting caught up in the details and aesthetics. By prioritizing the foundation and functionality of the prototype, designers can save time and effectively explore their ideas. This is applicable not only in game design but in various disciplines as well. So, the key takeaway is to embrace a quick and dirty approach in the prototyping phase, prioritizing functionality over aesthetics.

Embracing the Roughness: The Importance of Iteration in the Creative Process

The process of creating something great often starts with something rough and ugly. Tim Fessiss acknowledges that comparing his rough product to the finished work of others can be demoralizing. However, he gains confidence by seeing the original scripts and concept art that went through iterations and modifications before reaching the final product. Justin Gary reinforces this idea by sharing his own experience in game design and how his first prototypes were hideous. He encourages others to embrace the roughness and iterate on their ideas without getting hung up on making things pretty too early in the process. The key lesson here is that it is better to focus on fast prototyping and being open to change, rather than getting caught up in sunk cost fallacy and resistance to change.

Questioning assumptions and embracing conscious learning for personal and professional growth.

Assuming adults in the room always know what they are doing is an illusion. During a pivotal presentation, Justin realized that the executives he was pitching to lacked understanding about the project. This shattered his belief that those in authority always had the answers. It was a daunting moment, considering the project's financial risks, but also liberating. Justin realized that leadership is not about knowing everything or having exclusive knowledge. It is about being willing to make assertions and owning the consequences. This realization empowered him to take charge of his own future, applying principles like efficiency, automation, and fear-setting exercises. Justin's journey exemplifies that conscious learning and questioning assumptions are vital in achieving personal and professional growth.

Assessing Risks and Planning for Entrepreneurship

It is important to assess risks and have a plan before pursuing entrepreneurship. Justin Gary, in his journey towards entrepreneurship, focused on determining his minimal living expenses and saving up enough for a year of cushion. This allowed him to have the freedom to make decisions for the long term rather than being limited by short-term financial concerns. He also considered the worst-case scenarios and realized that they were often recoverable within a year or even less. Additionally, Justin emphasized the importance of being methodical and mitigating risks at every turn. While he didn't have a detailed plan, he created an open space to figure things out and took opportunities as they arose, such as contract work for another company.

Valuing Your Work and Overcoming Rejection as an Entrepreneur

Justin Gary realized the importance of valuing his work and not undercharging for his services. He initially faced rejection and laughter when he quoted his prices, but he learned from the experience. Justin's strategy was to double his asking price until he met resistance, which helped him determine the appropriate value for his work. Additionally, the conversation highlights the uncertainties and challenges of being an entrepreneur. The line between being an entrepreneur and just an individual with an idea can be blurred until tangible results are achieved. Justin also emphasized the value of pursuing projects that he found personally fulfilling and enjoyable, which led him to create something meaningful.

Building with passion and feedback for success

When creating a product or game, it is important to focus on your own passion and enjoyment. Building something that scratches your own itch and aligns with your interests is crucial for success. Avoid chasing trends, as this often leads to unsuccessful ventures. Instead, create something you truly love and believe in. Additionally, gathering feedback from others is essential in the development process. When people start asking to play your game or use your product without prompting, it is a positive sign that you have something special. However, it's crucial to consider your target audience and test with them in mind. Iterate based on feedback and continually invest in your product as it gains positive traction.

Resourcefulness and Adaptability in Game Development

Resourcefulness and adaptability are crucial in the game development industry. Justin Gary recounts how he utilized his friend's existing artwork to save costs and build the art style for his game. He also shares how he improvised with craft store beads to track victory points, which ended up impressing potential customers at a game convention. This demonstrates the importance of thinking outside the box and using what's available to create an appealing product. Furthermore, Justin's willingness to take a financial risk highlights the need for entrepreneurs to identify and capitalize on market demand. By demystifying risk and gathering positive feedback, he was able to make an informed decision. In the game industry, success often depends on leveraging creativity, adaptability, and market validation.

Standing out at trade shows and events: the key to success

In order to stand out and grab attention at trade shows or events, it is essential to have a great product and a reason for people to pay attention to you. It's not enough to simply have a booth or pay for space; you need to find ways to draw people in and separate yourself from the crowd. This can be done through unique components, visual displays, or even gimmicks that catch people's eye. However, it's important to remember that no amount of attention-grabbing tactics will help if you don't have a great product to back it up. Additionally, the value of real-life attention-grabbing, such as workshopping and gathering feedback, should not be underestimated in today's digital world.

The importance of feedback in the development process and how it evolves throughout different stages.

Eliciting and evaluating feedback is crucial in the development process, but the approach can vary depending on the phase of the project. In the early stages, the focus should be on testing whether the core idea or mechanic is fun, rather than on balance or aesthetics. As the project progresses, feedback on other aspects becomes more relevant. When seeking feedback, it is important to ask specific questions, such as what aspects the testers like or dislike, where they get confused, and what changes they would suggest. However, it is also important to pay attention to nonverbal cues and intuitively assess the relevance of feedback to the specific stage of development. Additionally, feedback from different types of testers, such as game designers or regular players, can offer valuable perspectives. Finally, when it comes to addressing feedback, it is important to remember that the testers may accurately identify a problem, but their proposed solutions may not always be the most effective.

The Importance of Gathering Feedback and Listening to Your Target Audience for Design Success

Gathering feedback and listening to your target audience is crucial for success as a designer. Justin Gary emphasizes the importance of paying attention to patterns and themes that emerge from user feedback. One person's opinion may be easily dismissed, but if multiple individuals from the target audience express the same concern or dislike, it should be taken seriously. Tim Fessiss adds that even if something appears visually appealing or well-crafted, if multiple people find it confusing or don't understand it, it needs to be omitted. This lesson is seen in Justin's experience at GenCon, where he receives feedback from early adopters and witnesses the viral success of his game. Additionally, Justin's encounter with a big gaming company highlights the potential benefits of collaboration and partnership.

Justin Gary's Risky Decision for Ownership Pays Off

Justin Gary's decision to keep ownership of his game, despite potential regrets, eventually paid off. He chose not to sell it off and instead saw it through until the end. Despite delays in the product launch and unexpected circumstances like launching while he was at Burning Man, the game sold out and gained popularity. This success allowed Justin to reorder and expand his company. The conversation also highlighted the economics of tabletop games, where margins are typically around 20% for game designers and manufacturers. Justin's decision to retain ownership was challenging due to the narrower margin gap, but it gave him the freedom to explore various expansion opportunities for his game, including derivative lines, movies, cartoons, and comic books.

Exploring different paths to success in game design and product development.

There are multiple paths to success as a game designer or product developer. Justin Gary emphasizes the joy of creating and growing storylines, of bringing worlds to life. However, he acknowledges that running a company also involves managing logistics, people, and marketing strategies. He believes that selling to a publisher can be a great strategy for those who solely want to make games. On the other hand, Tim Fessiss highlights the option of licensing to a larger company for broader distribution and impact on culture. The key is to define what success means to you and why you're pursuing this path. It's essential to avoid chasing dollars as the primary goal and instead focus on the deeper purpose behind your work. By recognizing the different possibilities and staying true to your objectives, you can navigate the ups and downs of the entrepreneurial journey.

Lessons in Game Development: Financial Planning, Resilience, and Perseverance

Justin Gary's journey in game development taught him valuable lessons about the importance of realistic financial planning, resilience, and accepting failure. Initially, Justin's success with his first project, Ascension, made him overconfident and led him to underestimate the costs involved in creating a digital game. As a result, he faced financial challenges and had to resort to borrowing money and accumulating debt. However, through perseverance and making difficult decisions, he was able to turn the situation around. Justin's experience highlights the significance of being prepared for worst-case scenarios, adapting strategies to reduce risks, and maintaining a determined mindset in the face of adversity.

Building successful partnerships and businesses through communication, honesty, and a growth mindset.

Communication, honesty, and a growth mindset are essential for building successful partnerships and businesses. Justin Gary emphasizes the importance of being honest with your partners, conveying bad news, and admitting when ideas are not working. He also highlights the need for humility and recognizing that nobody knows everything. Justin and his partner Richard were able to maintain a strong relationship by practicing integrity and embracing the fact that not every venture will be successful. Additionally, Justin shares his insights on running a company, drawing parallels between designing a great game and designing a great company. Clear goals, constant feedback, appropriate challenges, and a winning mindset are crucial elements in both endeavors. By applying these principles, Justin has streamlined and simplified his company's operations.

Cultivating a Productive and Connected Mindset

Cultivating a mindset focused on clear goals and staying connected is vital for success. Justin Gary emphasizes the importance of structuring his company based on design principles and applying them to daily operations. He uses a company Discord to ensure everyone knows their priorities for the day, week, month, and quarter. This method helps the team stay connected and accountable, especially since they work remotely. It forces individuals to assess what is truly important and avoid getting caught up in distractions. While there is minimal follow-up on daily goals, weekly goals are reviewed and discussed as a form of accountability. Discord was chosen as a productivity tool due to its ease of use, file-sharing capabilities, and the ability to interact with the fan community. The mobile experience with Discord is functional, allowing for specific and intentional usage. Overall, this conversation highlights the significance of clear goals, connection, accountability, and effective communication in achieving productivity and success.

The Power of Letting Go: How Trusting Others Leads to Growth and Success

Letting go of control can lead to positive outcomes in leadership and management. Justin Gary, who had a tendency to micromanage his team, realized during a three-week trip to Thailand that he had been holding his team back. By stepping away and giving his team the opportunity to take initiative and make decisions, he discovered that they were perfectly capable of handling tasks and solving problems on their own. This allowed them to grow and become more effective in their roles. Justin's experience shows that relinquishing control and trusting others can lead to better outcomes and a more empowered team. It's important for leaders to create systems and set clear expectations, but also to give their team the freedom to learn from mistakes and make meaningful contributions.

Embracing uncertainty for a smoother life

Cultivating comfort with uncertainty and impermanence can make life much easier. Justin Gary shares his personal mantra of embracing the unknown and accepting the fact that things will always change. Many of our fears and anxieties come from the fear of the unknown and the fear of losing something. However, if we can let go of our need for control and be okay with not knowing what the future holds, we can find peace and navigate life more smoothly. This mindset applies to all aspects of life, whether it's pursuing a creative path, building relationships, or making important decisions. Embracing uncertainty is a powerful tool that can bring greater ease and fulfillment.