Share this post

🔑 Key Takeaways

  1. Rail transportation offers advantages in efficiency and cost, while driverless trucks pose a competitive advantage in labor costs. Innovations and adaptations are needed for railways to maintain their competitive edge.
  2. Balancing the needs of passenger and freight trains is crucial for safe and efficient transportation. PSR helps optimize operations by running longer trains and ensuring infrastructure can accommodate their size.
  3. Striking a balance between efficiency and resilience is crucial in implementing PSR. Continuous pursuit of operational excellence ensures the right level of efficiency while maintaining the ability to sustain operations in the long term.
  4. Honesty about limitations, customization, and reliability are key factors in maintaining commitments, offering a superior product, and establishing long-term customer relationships.
  5. Service, capacity planning, and collaboration between stakeholders are crucial for optimizing supply chains and meeting customer demands in the transportation industry.
  6. Effective coordination between railroads, ports, and governments is essential to optimize transportation capacity and ensure efficient export. A systematic approach to execution helps prevent overcommitment and promotes cost control and reliable services for customers.
  7. Effective leaders create a vision, select the right people, foster a positive culture, and deliver results by assembling a capable team, cultivating a supportive environment, and setting high standards.
  8. Optimizing processes, paying attention to details, and making tough decisions are crucial for achieving better service, lower costs, and improved asset utilization in any business.
  9. Leaders must not ignore rule violations or unsafe acts, but instead initiate uncomfortable conversations and address conflicts to prioritize safety and set an example for others. Consistently enforcing rules is essential to maintaining a strong safety culture.
  10. Taking responsibility and standing up for what we believe is right, even if it means admitting our own mistakes, is crucial for creating a safer and more sustainable environment.
  11. Prioritizing long-term sustainability and safety is crucial in business, even when facing short-term pressures for quarterly success. Consistently prioritizing safe and efficient operations leads to lasting success.
  12. By recognizing the need to expand their reach, investing in infrastructure, and seizing opportunities, the company achieved significant growth, increased revenue, and attractive margins despite pandemic challenges.
  13. Facing competition, Keith and his team's superior value proposition and shared vision allowed them to secure a merger agreement, highlighting the importance of preparation, determination, and seizing opportunities.
  14. Strategic negotiations require evaluating scenarios, presenting factual information, and focusing on value. Betting on the trust model and remaining patient can lead to favorable outcomes.
  15. Keith Creel's strategic move to convince KCS shareholders to choose CP over CN aligns with his belief in serving a greater purpose and will create significant value for all stakeholders.

📝 Podcast Summary

The role of rail transportation in the economy and its potential challenges and opportunities in the face of driverless trucks.

Rail transportation plays a vital role in the economy by enabling the efficient movement of goods. Rails offer advantages such as lower costs, larger carrying capacity, and dedicated assets that improve efficiency compared to trucks. However, trucks excel in certain areas due to their agility, flexibility, and reliability for just-in-time inventories and transportation of goods to specific destinations. The development of driverless trucks poses a potential challenge and opportunity for railways, as it could provide a competitive advantage in terms of labor costs. While driverless trains exist in some parts of the world, implementing them on a wider scale in the United States faces technological and societal challenges, including regulations and the workforce's acceptance of change. Innovations and adaptations will be necessary for railways to maintain their competitive advantage in the evolving transportation landscape.

The challenges of mixing passenger and freight trains and the role of precision scheduled railroading (PSR) in optimizing train operations.

The limitations and complexities of mixing passenger and freight trains create a disconnect in terms of speed and infrastructure. Freight trains are heavy and limited by weight, while passenger trains can move faster but require dedicated tracks. Mixing the two can lead to safety concerns and capacity issues. Precision scheduled railroading (PSR) plays a role in optimizing train operations by running fewer but longer trains and ensuring infrastructure is designed to accommodate their size. PSR involves defining and managing processes to create an efficient service that meets customer needs. Overall, balancing the needs of both passenger and freight trains is crucial to ensure safe and efficient transportation.

Implementing PSR for Efficient Railway Operations

Implementing precision scheduled railroad (PSR) can lead to increased efficiency and cost savings in the railway industry. By optimizing assets, such as locomotives, rail cars, track infrastructure, and switches, companies can do more with less and run their operations more efficiently. This process of refining and executing good practices through people and culture can be applied to various manufacturing businesses, airlines, trucking, and other industries. However, it is important to strike a balance between efficiency and resilience. Overengineering or cutting too deeply can harm a company's ability to sustain its operations in the long term. It is a continuous journey of pursuing operational excellence and finding that sweet spot where efficiency meets the need for redundancy and guardrails.

Importance of Managing Capacity and Meeting Customer Demands

Managing capacity and meeting customer demands are crucial for the success of a business. Keith Creel emphasizes the importance of not oversubscribing the network, as it can lead to a meltdown and failure to deliver. He shares an example of a contract negotiation where he had to be honest with the customer about the limitations of his network. By customizing the lanes they serve, they were able to maintain their commitments while still offering a superior product. Keith also highlights the significance of reliability and being a service provider that delivers on their promises. Customers are willing to pay more for a reliable service and establish long-term relationships based on trust.

Importance of Service, Capacity Planning, and Collaboration in Transportation Industry

Service and capacity planning are crucial factors in the transportation industry. Keith Creel emphasizes the importance of service and the willingness to pay a premium for faster delivery. He also highlights the risks of solely focusing on price without considering the reliability and capability of the transportation provider. On the other hand, he acknowledges the challenges of forecasting capacity, especially in industries with significant variability like grain. Creel emphasizes the need to balance surge capacity and long-term sustainability, as building for peak demand can be detrimental to the company in the long run. Additionally, he discusses how the rail network must evolve to adapt to changing trends such as onshoring and reshoring. Collaboration between governments, customers, and industry players is essential for optimizing capacity and improving supply chains.

Importance of Coordination and Partnership in Logistics and Transportation Systems

Effective coordination and partnership between various stakeholders are crucial for optimizing logistics and transportation systems. Keith Creel highlights the importance of partnerships between railroads and ports to ensure that the capacity created inland matches the capacity available at the ports for efficient export. He also mentions that railroads do not own terminals due to government ownership or private ownership, which necessitates coordination between railroads, customers, and governments. Creel emphasizes the significance of a systematic approach to execution, where a dedicated team assesses and matches track capacity, yard capacity, personnel, and assets before securing business. This approach helps prevent overcommitment and inefficiencies, promoting cost control, good margins, and reliable services for customers.

The key elements of effective leadership and how they lead to success

Effective leadership requires creating a vision, selecting the right people, fostering a positive culture, and delivering results. According to Keith Creel, who worked with renowned leader Hunter Harrison, the number one job of a leader is to produce results. This can only be achieved by assembling a capable team, cultivating a supportive environment, and providing motivation. When individuals are given the opportunity to contribute to something greater than themselves, they experience a sense of accomplishment and pride, leading to success. Moreover, great leaders like Harrison set high standards and challenge their team members to surpass their limits. They push individuals to stretch their abilities and achieve more than they believed possible, resulting in personal growth.

The Importance of Understanding the Unintended Consequences in Business

Understanding the unintended consequences and long-term impact of our actions is crucial in business. Keith Creel shares his experience of receiving a phone call from Hunter Harrison, the CEO, questioning why he left 10 cars off a shipment. At first, Keith couldn't comprehend the significance, but Hunter explained that it wasn't just about those 10 cars. It affected the entire cycle of operations, causing imbalances, inefficiencies, and additional costs. Hunter emphasized the importance of optimizing processes and deep diving into the details to achieve better service, lower costs, and improved asset utilization. He also emphasized the need for leaders to make tough decisions and drive change, even if uncomfortable. These lessons are universally applicable and lead to success in any business.

Taking Responsibility for a Safe Work Environment

Creating a safe work environment requires leaders to take responsibility and address rule violations. Keith Creel emphasizes the importance of not looking the other way when employees engage in unsafe acts or violate rules. He believes that leaders must step into uncomfortable conversations and address conflicts, even if it means confronting their own employees. By doing so, they show that they prioritize safety and set an example for others to follow. Keith also highlights the importance of knowing and enforcing the rules consistently, as failure to do so not only validates bad behavior but also undermines the safety culture within the organization. Ultimately, leaders must prioritize safety over their own comfort to protect the well-being of employees and prevent potential accidents.

Confronting Uncomfortable Situations for Positive Change

Sometimes we must confront uncomfortable situations and address them directly in order to create positive change. Keith Creel shared an example where he noticed a crew member smoking on a locomotive and decided to take action, despite the potential backlash or discomfort it may cause. He recognized that allowing this behavior to continue would compromise safety and send the wrong message to other crew members. This story emphasizes the importance of taking responsibility and standing up for what we believe is right, even if it means admitting our own mistakes and investing time and effort into addressing the issue. It also highlights the long-term view and commitment to sustainability that Bill Ackman demonstrated as an activist investor at Canadian Pacific.

Balancing Short-Term Success with Long-Term Sustainability in Business

In business, balancing short-term and long-term goals is crucial. As a publicly traded company, there is pressure to show quarterly success, but it should never come at the expense of long-term sustainability and safety. Keith Creel emphasizes the importance of maintaining a balance between satisfying short-term and long-term investors. He shares his experience of facing the worst financial quarter but being able to explain the reasons and commit to improvement in the next quarter. Creel also highlights the significance of understanding the long game, especially in industries like railroads that play a vital role in the economy. The conversation highlights the importance of considering the long-term consequences and consistently prioritizing safe and efficient operations over short-term gains.

Expanding Reach for Growth and Success

The company recognized the need to expand its reach in order to thrive and compete in the market. Despite being financially stable, the company realized that without reaching all markets, it was limited in its ability to serve customers effectively. Therefore, they sought opportunities to expand their network and increase their customer base. Through a successful transaction, they were able to acquire additional reach and tap into a new market, leading to significant growth and success. They utilized their financial stability to invest in infrastructure and create solutions for customers, resulting in increased revenue and attractive margins. Despite the challenges posed by the pandemic, the company continued to create success and identified an opportunity to further grow their network through a strategic merger.

Overcoming Competition and Seizing Opportunity: The Story of a Successful Merger

Keith Creel, the speaker, is sharing the story of how a potential investor's interest in buying their company triggered a process that led to a merger agreement with another company. Despite facing competition from private equity, Keith and his team engaged with the opportunity and ultimately defeated the competition due to the superior value their deal could provide and their shared vision for creating long-term value. The speaker expresses excitement about the potential of the merger and the positive energy surrounding the opportunities it presents. Additionally, Keith mentions being prepared for a competitive response from Canadian National, a railroad company, and the unexpected strength of their entry into the game. Nonetheless, Keith is determined to fight for the merger.

Strategic Negotiations: Trust, Value, and Patience

Keith Creel and his team meticulously prepared for negotiations by evaluating different scenarios, considering financial capabilities, and analyzing the balance sheet. They recognized the importance of certainty and value in any deal and focused on presenting factual information to defeat their opponent. Instead of engaging in a bidding war, Keith emphasized the importance of fighting their competitor's ability to get their bid approved by the regulator. They strategically bet on the trust model, knowing that it would only be approved if it served the public interest through increased competition. Despite the aggressive tactics of their opponent, Keith and his team remained patient, waiting for the trust ruling and not allowing themselves to be trapped in a potentially unfavorable transaction.

Keith Creel successfully convinces KCS shareholders to reject CN and rejoin CP, emphasizing the value and network CP offers, and the risks of a trust with CN.

Keith Creel, CEO of Canadian Pacific (CP), successfully convinced Kansas City Southern (KCS) shareholders to reject the deal with Canadian National (CN) and sign back up with CP. Creel emphasized two main points: first, CN could not replicate the value and network that CP offered, and second, the uncertainty of a trust with CN was not worth the risk. The Surface Transportation Board (STB) ultimately turned down CN's trust proposal with a unanimous decision. Creel acknowledges that CP overpaid, but believes the merger will create huge value for all stakeholders, including employees, shareholders, and the communities they serve. This merger is seen as necessary for global commerce and aligns with Creel's core belief in serving a greater purpose than oneself. Overall, CP's strategic move to reengage with KCS aligns with their long-term goals and values.