Share this post

🔑 Key Takeaways

  1. The pandemic has affected college admissions, with some students benefiting from canceled SATs while others face challenges and need additional support.
  2. The pandemic has led to a decrease in college applications, with students opting for gap years or community college. However, some prestigious universities are experiencing a surge in applications due to SAT requirements being waived. Admissions officers are uncertain about the future consequences.
  3. College choice plays a significant role in determining social mobility, with attending highly selective schools increasing the chances of economic success. The shift towards test-optional admissions during the pandemic has opened doors for students previously excluded based on SAT scores.
  4. Standardized tests like the SAT disadvantage students from lower-income families, perpetuating inequality in educational opportunities. High school grades are a better predictor of college success than SAT scores alone.
  5. Test-optional policies have shown positive outcomes in increasing diversity and access to higher education, but financial constraints still hinder disadvantaged students from gaining equal opportunities.
  6. Limited financial aid and pressure on colleges to generate revenue create obstacles for low-income and first-generation students, leading to decreased access to quality higher education.
  7. The pandemic has prompted a reevaluation of standardized tests in college admissions, with some seeing the removal of the SAT as an opportunity to increase access and diversity in admissions outcomes.
  8. Admissions directors have found that they can successfully evaluate students based on other application aspects, but there are differing opinions on the future of standardized tests in college admissions.
  9. Removing SAT and ACT requirements in college admissions allows for a more diverse freshman class, providing equal opportunities for students from underprivileged backgrounds to pursue higher education.
  10. With the right support and resources, students from less rigorous academic backgrounds can thrive in college and succeed in their courses. Building relationships, offering therapy-like office hours, and pushing students to challenge themselves can help overcome academic anxiety and self-doubt.
  11. Effort, determination, and the right support can help students overcome obstacles and achieve academic success, regardless of their initial test scores.
  12. Providing support and resources to struggling freshman students, such as peer mentors, study groups, and counseling, can significantly improve academic success and college experience.
  13. The top 10% program and elimination of the SAT requirement in college admissions can increase access to prestigious universities and promote diversity by considering individual potential and providing equal opportunities for students from underrepresented communities.

📝 Podcast Summary

The Impact of the Pandemic on College Admissions and Efforts to Support Students during Difficult Times

College admissions have been greatly affected by the pandemic. Lorraine, a high school student, saw her opportunity to apply to prestigious universities increase when they went test optional due to SAT cancellations. She was thrilled and felt like she had a shot at her dream schools without having to submit higher SAT scores. However, not all students have been as fortunate. Many are falling through the cracks and ghosting their counselors due to the challenges brought about by the pandemic. High school counselor Valerie Gonzalez and her team have even resorted to going door to door to reach out to these students. This highlights the immense impact of the pandemic on college admissions and the efforts being made to support students during these difficult times.

The pandemic has greatly impacted college admissions and the choices students are making. Many students are opting to take a year off or attend community college due to various factors such as financial concerns, personal safety, and the shift to online learning. As a result, colleges are experiencing a significant decrease in applications, especially less selective schools, which can lead to financial challenges. Interestingly, some well-known and prestigious universities are seeing a surge in applications, likely due to the absence of SAT requirements. The uncertainty caused by these changes has left admissions officers feeling confused and fearful about the future. It remains to be seen whether these shifts will have a lasting impact on the college admissions process.

The Impact of College Choice on Social Mobility and the Changing Role of SAT Scores in the Application Process.

The college application process is a crucial opportunity for social mobility for students in the United States. Going to college opens doors to higher income, longer life expectancy, and increased happiness. However, where you go to college matters significantly. Research shows that attending highly selective schools like Ivy League institutions increases the chances of reaching the top 1% of earners as an adult. On the other hand, attending community college or not going to college at all significantly decreases those chances. The SAT, as a sorting mechanism for college admissions, has faced much criticism and debate. Many colleges have recently become test-optional, and during the pandemic, even the most selective schools followed suit. This shift has created an opportunity for students who may have been previously excluded based on their SAT scores.

The Disparities in Standardized Testing and College Admissions

Standardized tests, like the SAT, heavily favor students from higher-income families. The story of Daniela and her classmates highlights the disparities in test scores based on socioeconomic status. Students who come from wealthier backgrounds have more resources, such as expensive SAT prep courses and private tutors, which give them an advantage. This advantage extends beyond test preparation and includes factors like better schools and neighborhoods. The frustrating part for Daniela was that despite her performance in class, the test seemed to undermine her confidence and question her abilities. It is important to consider that high school grades are a better predictor of college success than SAT scores alone. Using standardized tests in admissions may lead to rejecting capable students, perpetuating the inequality in educational opportunities.

The Impact of Standardized Testing and the Potential of Test-Optional Policies.

Standardized tests like the SAT can have a disproportionate impact on low-income, first-generation, and non-white students, keeping them out of elite colleges. These tests often provide false negatives, making it difficult for deserving students to gain admission to their top-choice schools. However, the recent trend of colleges going test optional due to the pandemic has shown some promising results. Schools like Georgia Tech, which saw an increase in applications from a more diverse pool of students, have been able to admit higher numbers of underrepresented students. However, financial constraints remain a significant barrier, as many colleges, including Georgia Tech, do not meet a high percentage of students' financial needs. Ultimately, while test optional policies may increase access, financial aid and affordability continue to pose challenges for students from disadvantaged backgrounds.

Financial Constraints: Barriers to Elite Education for Low-Income Students

The financial constraints faced by colleges and universities play a significant role in limiting the opportunities for low-income and first-generation students to attend elite and prestigious schools. Despite being highly qualified, these students often end up choosing less selective and cheaper institutions close to home due to the limited financial aid available. The financial pressure on colleges to generate revenue from tuition leaves them with a difficult decision of admitting students who can contribute to their bottom line. This situation has only been exacerbated by the financial challenges brought on by the pandemic, causing further budget cuts and layoffs at even the wealthiest institutions. As a result, it is expected that the number of low-income and first-generation students attending college will decline, highlighting the ongoing struggle for access to quality higher education due to financial limitations.

The Changing Role of Standardized Tests in College Admissions

The pandemic has brought about a shift in the use of standardized tests like the SAT in college admissions. While some admissions directors are relieved to be rid of the SAT, others still see its value in predicting a student's ability to succeed in college. Test optional policies have allowed schools to consider other aspects of a student's application, such as their unique experiences and diverse backgrounds. However, it remains to be seen whether this change will result in increased access and diversity in the overall admissions outcomes. The admissions process is still ongoing, and only time will tell if the removal of the SAT truly opens doors for students who previously may not have been considered.

Test-optional admissions: Challenges and considerations for colleges

Many admissions directors have found that going test optional this year did not make admissions decisions significantly more difficult. In fact, it proved to them that they could still select students they were happy with by focusing on other aspects of the application, such as transcripts, essays, letters of recommendation, and interviews. The rigor of a student's curriculum, including advanced placement classes, also became more important in the absence of SAT scores. Looking ahead, some admissions directors believe that their schools might have to continue to stay test optional in order to compete with other schools that will also remain test optional. However, there are varying opinions on this matter, and some elite schools may see advantages in going back to requiring the SATs for reputation and financial reasons. The future of standardized tests like the SAT and ACT remains uncertain, as colleges and universities evaluate the success and performance of students admitted without these tests during the pandemic.

Promoting diversity and inclusivity in college admissions by removing standardized tests.

Removing the requirement for SAT and ACT tests in college admissions can lead to a more diverse and unique freshman class. The University of Texas at Austin, which admits students based strictly on class rank and disregards SAT scores, is a prime example. This approach allows students with excellent grades from various high schools, even if their test scores may not be as strong, to have the opportunity to attend a prestigious university. Students like Ivonne, who came from a disadvantaged background, didn't let their lower test scores deter them from pursuing higher education. This shift in admissions criteria creates a safety net for students who may not excel in standardized testing but excel in other academic areas. Consequently, it promotes inclusivity and provides equal opportunities for students from underprivileged backgrounds.

Helping Students Overcome Academic Obstacles in College

The transition from high school to college can be difficult for students who come from less rigorous academic backgrounds. Students like Ivonne, who face a mismatch between their high school grades and lower standardized test scores, often struggle initially in college. However, studies have shown that these students can perform well and succeed in good colleges. It is important for colleges and universities to provide additional support and resources to help these students adjust and thrive. Professors like Uri Treisman, who prioritize building relationships, offering therapy-like office hours, and pushing students to challenge themselves, can help struggling students overcome academic anxiety and self-doubt. By fostering a belief in their abilities, these students can catch up and succeed in their courses.

The importance of individualized attention and a supportive learning environment in academic success.

Academic performance and intelligence should not be solely measured by standardized test scores such as the SAT. The story of Ivonne and the support she received from her professors highlights the importance of individualized attention and a supportive learning environment. Despite initially struggling and feeling like she was falling behind, Ivonne's professors believed in her potential and provided the necessary support to help her succeed. This challenges the common assumption that lower SAT scores indicate lower intelligence or potential. It emphasizes that effort, determination, and the right support can enable students to overcome obstacles and achieve academic success, regardless of their initial test scores.

Creating Supportive Environments for Freshman Success

Providing support and resources to struggling freshman students can have a profound impact on their academic success and overall college experience. Paul Tough, along with David Laude, implemented various support programs at UT Austin, including peer mentors, study groups, counseling, and tutoring centers, which helped students like Ivonne thrive. The importance of creating a supportive and inclusive environment is highlighted by Ivonne's transformation from failure and despair to becoming a successful math major. This success extended beyond the first year, as Sandra Black's research shows that students admitted through the top 10% program at UT Austin had higher graduation rates and better long-term earnings. It emphasizes the need to provide necessary support during the crucial first semesters of college to ensure student success.

Expanding Opportunities for College Admissions and Diversity

The top 10% program in college admissions has a significant impact on students' paths and opportunities. Without this program, students like Ivonne could have missed out on the chance to attend prestigious universities like the University of Texas and Harvard. The elimination of the SAT requirement in college admissions opens up doors for more students to showcase their abilities and prove themselves academically. This shift in the admissions process provides hope for greater diversity and equal access to higher education. By considering alternative criteria and focusing on individual potential, more students from low-income backgrounds and underrepresented communities can pursue their dreams and achieve success.